汤峰;苏毓淞;

• 1:清华大学社会科学学院政治学系
• 2:清华大学政治学系

摘要(Abstract)：

20世纪末,比较政治学界对一些转型国家政权稳固而另一些转型国家政权频繁更迭这一现象表现出浓厚兴趣,学者试图用"体制性整合"来阐释上述现象。本文围绕"体制性整合如何促进政权稳定"这一核心议题,对体制性整合理论进行系统讨论。体制性整合具有多重含义,可以指过程、手段、策略以及机制等。该理论能够为政权稳定提供较好的解释,但也存在局限,如理论解释与经验事实间不对称,研究视角上忽视国际环境和政党等因素,内在机制不完善等。因此,在运用该理论进行分析的过程中应充分考虑国际宏观因素和政党,尝试进行案例研究、引入实验法和完善研究设计,这可能是体制性整合理论未来研究的可行方向。

关键词(KeyWords)： 比较政治学;转型国家;体制性整合;政权稳定

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 清华大学春风基金资助项目的研究成果

作者(Author): 汤峰;苏毓淞;

Email:

DOI: 10.16091/j.cnki.cn32-1308/c.2021.01.015

参考文献(References)：

• ①P.Selznick，“Foundations of the Theory of Organization”,American Sociological Review,Vol.13,No.1(1948),pp.25-35．
• ②(15)M.Holdo，“Cooptation and Non-cooptation:Elite Strategies in Response to Social Protest”,Social Movement Studies,Vol.18,No.4(2019),pp.444-462,pp.444-462．
• ③参见G.O’Donnell,Modernization and Bureaucratic-Authoritarianism:Studies in South American Politics,CA:Institute of International Studies,1973,pp.88-92;J.Gandhi,Political Institutions under Dictatorship,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2008,H.I.Grossman，“Production,Appropriation,and Land Reform”,The American Economic Review,Vol.84,No.3(1994),pp.705-712;D.Acemoglu,&J.Robinson，“Why did the West Extend the Franchise?Democracy,Inequality,and Growth in Historical Perspective”,The Quarterly Journal of Economics,Vol.115,No.4(2000),pp.1167-1199．
• ④J.A.Goldstone，“Toward a Fourth Generation of Revolutionary Theory”,Annual Review of Political Science,Vol.4,No.1(2001),pp.139-187．
• ⑤⑩(22)M.Svolik,The Politics of Authoritarian Rule,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2012,pp.2-3,p.124,p.165
• ⑥R.Wintrobe,The Political Economy of Dictatorship,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1998,pp.20-39;J.Gandhi,&A.Przeworski，“Authoritarian Institutions and the Survival of Autocrats”,Comparative Political Studies,Vol.40,No.1(2007),pp.1279-1301;D.Acemoglu,&J.A.Robinson，“A Theory of Political Transitions”,American Economic Review,Vol.191,No.91 (2001),pp.938-963;C.Boix,Democracy and Redistribution,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2003．
• ⑦参见B.Geddes，“Party Creation as an Autocratic Survival Strategy”,Presented at Dictatorships:Their Governance and Social Consequences,Conference at Princeton University,2008;M.Svolik，“Power Sharing and Leadership Dynamics in Authoritarian Regimes”,American Journal of Political Science,Vol.53,No.2(2009),pp.477-494;M.Svolik,The Politics of Authoritarian Rule,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2012,pp.3-6．
• ⑧D.Mc Adam,J.D.Mc Carthy,&M.N.Zald,Comparative Perspectives on Social Movements:Political Opportunities,Mobilizing Structures,and Cultural Framings,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1996．
• ⑨B.De Mesquita,&A.Smith，“Leader Survival,Revolutions,and the Nature of Government Finance”,American Journal of Political Science,Vol.54,No.4 (2010),pp.936-950;M.Albertus,&V.Menaldo，“Coercive Capacity and the Prospects for Democratization”,Comparative Politics,Vol.44,No.2(2012),pp.151-169．
• (11)W.H.Moore，“Repression and Dissent:Substitution,Context,and Timing”,American Journal of Political Science,Vol.42,No.3(1998),pp.851-873．
• (12)T.Kuran，“Now out of Never:The Element of Surprise in the East European Revolution of 1989”,World politics,Vol.44,No.1(1991),pp.7-48．
• (13)E.Lust-Okar,Structuring Conflict In The Arab World:Incumbents,Opponents,and Institutions,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2005;B.Magaloni，“The Game of Electoral Fraud and the Ousting of Authoritarian Rule”,American Journal of Political Science,Vol.54,No.3(2010),pp.751-765．
• (14)(21)E.Frantz,&A.Kendall-Taylor，“A Dictator’s Toolkit:Understanding How Co-Optation Affects Repression in Autocracies”,Journal of Peace Research,Vol.51,No.3(2014),pp.332-346,pp.332-346．
• (16)W.Kim,&J.Gandhi，“Coopting Workers Under Dictatorship”,The Journal of Politics,Vol.72,No.3(2010),pp.646-658．
• (17)B.Magaloni,&R.Kricheli，“Political Order and One-Party Rule”,Annual Review of Political Science,Vol.13 (2010),pp.123-143．
• (18) Jr F.J.Fleron，“Cooptation as a Mechanism of Adaption to Change:The Soviet Political Leadership System”,Polity,Vol.2,No.2(1969),pp.176-201．
• (19)R.Wintrobe,The Political Economy of Dictatorship,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1998．
• (20)J.Gandhi,&A.Przeworski，“Authoritarian Institutions and the Survival of Autocrats”,Comparative Political Studies,Vol.40,No.11(2007),pp.1279-1301;J.Gandhi,&A.Przeworski，“Cooperation,Cooptation,and Rebellion Under Dictatorships”,Economics&Politics,Vol.18,No.1(2006),pp.1-26．
• (23)(26)(39)(44)B.Magaloni，“Credible Power-sharing and the Longevity of Authoritarian Rule”,Comparative Political Studies,Vol.41,No.4-5(2008),pp.715-741,pp.715-741,pp.715-741,pp.715-741．
• (24)(35)B.Geddes，“What Do We Know About Democratization After Twenty Years?”Annual Review of Political Science,Vol.2,No.1(1999),pp.115-144,pp.115-144．
• (25)D.Gershenson,&H.I.Grossman，“Cooption and Repression in the Soviet Union”,Economics&Politics,Vol.13,No.1(2001),pp.31-47．
• (27)B.Magaloni,&R.Kricheli，“Political Order and One-Party Rule”,Annual Review of Political Science,Vol.13 (2010),pp.123-143;B.Geddes,&J.Wright,&E.Frantz，“Autocratic Breakdown and Regime Transitions:A New Data Set”,Perspectives on Politics,Vol.12,No.2(2014),pp.313-331．
• (28)(30) J.Gandhi,Political Institutions Under Dictatorship,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2008．
• (29)B.Magaloni，“Credible Power-sharing and the Longevity of Authoritarian Rule”,Comparative Political Studies,Vol.41,No.4-5 (2008),pp.715-741;C.Boix,&M.Svolik，“The Foundations of Limited Authoritarian Government:Institutions,Commitment,and Power-sharing in Dictatorships”,The Journal of Politics,Vol.75,No.2(2013),pp.300-316;M.Svolik,The Politics of Authoritarian Rule,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2012,p.163．
• (31)D.Acemoglu,&J.A.Robinson,Economic Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2005;B.Magaloni，“Credible Power-sharing and the Longevity of Authoritarian Rule”,Comparative Political Studies,Vol.41,No.4-5 (2008),pp.715-741;C.Boix,&M.Svolik，“The Foundations of Limited Authoritarian Government:Institutions,Commitment,and Power-sharing in Dictatorships”,The Journal of Politics,Vol.75,No.2 (2013),pp.300-31;J.Wright,&A.Escribà-Folch，“Authoritarian Institutions and Regime Survival:Transitions to Democracy and Subsequent Autocracy”,British Journal of Political Science,Vol.42,No.2(2012),pp.283-309．
• (32)A.Baturo,&R.Elgie，“Why Do Authoritarian Regimes Adopt Bicameralism?Cooptation,Control,and Masking Controversial Reforms”,Democratization,Vol.25,No.5(2018),pp.919-937．
• (33)参见J.Gandhi,&A.Przeworski，“Authoritarian Institutions and the Survival of Autocrats”,Comparative Political Studies,Vol.40,No.11(2007),pp.1279-1301;C.Boix,&M.Svolik，“The Foundations of Limited Authoritarian Government:Institutions,Commitment,and Power-sharing in Dictatorships”,The Journal of Politics,Vol.75,No.2 (2013),pp.300-316;O.J.Reuter,&G.B.Robertson，“Legislatures,Cooptation,and Social Protest in Contemporary Authoritarian Regimes”,The Journal of Politics,Vol.77,No.1(2015),pp.235-248．
• (34)J.Wright，“Do Authoritarian Institutions Constrain?How Legislatures Affect Economic Growth and Investment”,American Journal of Political Science,Vol.52,No.2(2008),pp.322-343．
• (36)B.Magaloni,Voting for Autocracy:Hegemonic Party Survival and Its Demise in Mexico,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2006,p.6;B.Magaloni,&R.Kricheli，“Political Order and One-Party Rule”,Annual Review of Political Science,Vol.13(2010),pp.123-143．
• (37)J.Gandhi,&E.Lust-Okar，“Elections Under Authoritarianism”,Annual Review of Political Science,Vol.12(2009),pp.403-422;E.Lust-Okar,&A.Jamal，“Rulers and Rules:Reassessing the Influence of Regime Type on Electoral Law Formation”,Comparative Political Studies,Vol.35,No.3(2002),pp.337-366．
• (38) L.A.Blaydes,Competition Without Democracy:Elections and Distributive Politics in Mubarak’s Egypt,University of California,Los Angeles,2008,p.11;L.R.Arriola，“Patronage and Political Stability in Africa”,Comparative Political Studies,Vol.42,No.10(2009),pp.1339-1362．
• (40)B.De Mesquita,A.Smith,M S.Randolph,&J D.Morrow,The Logic of Political Survival,CA:MIT press,2005,p.8．
• (41)E.Malesky,&P.Schuler，“Nodding or Needling:Analyzing Delegate Responsiveness in an Authoritarian Parliament”,A-merican Political Science Review,Vol.104,No.3(2010),pp.482-502．
• (42)O.J.Reuter,&G.B.Robertson，“Legislatures,Cooptation,and Social Protest in Contemporary Authoritarian Regimes”,The Journal of Politics,Vol.77,No.1(2015),pp.235-248．
• (43)C.Boix,&M.W.Svolik，“The Foundations of Limited Authoritarian Government:Institutions,Commitment,and Powersharing in Dictatorships”,The Journal of Politics,Vol.75,No.2(2013),pp.300-316．
• (45)P.H.O’Neil，“Revolution from within:Institutional Analysis,Transitions from Authoritarianism,and the Case of Hungary”,World Politics,No.4,Vol.48 (1996),pp.579-603;Y Q.Tong，“State,Society,and Political Change in China and Hungary”,Comparative Politics,Vol.26,No.3(1994),pp.333-353.