欧洲公地制度的政治学遗产
赵文洪;
摘要(Abstract)：
中世纪的欧洲公地共同体公共事务的管理,一定程度上体现着民主、平等和法治的精神:民主精神体现在共同体全体成员广泛直接参与庄园法庭和村民会议的立法、决策、司法活动以及选举和担任共同事务管理者;平等精神体现于共同体成员公共权利价值的平等、在村规面前的平等;在管理共同事务的资格方面的平等。法治精神体现于法律至上、法律面前人人平等、重视法律程序。民主平等法治精神,是公地制度留给后世的政治学遗产。
关键词(KeyWords)： 欧洲公地共同体;政治学遗产;民主;平等;法治
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Authors): 赵文洪;
DOI: 10.16091/j.cnki.cn32-1308/c.2011.02.016
参考文献(References)：
- [1]对这一制度内容的介绍,以及对国内关于它的研究状况的介绍,参见拙著《中世纪欧洲村庄的自治》,《世界历史》2007年第3期;《庄园法庭、村规民约与中世纪欧洲“公地共同体”》,《历史研究》2007年第4期。
- [3][5]2344C.S.&C.S.Orwin,The Open Fields,Oxford at TheClarendon Press,1967,p.124;p.125,p.126,p.146,p.158;p.134;p.127,p.128,p.130.
- [4]C.S.Orwin,“Observations onthe Open Fields”,The Economic His-tory Review,Vol.8,No.2(May,1938),p.135.
- [6]J.A.Yelling,Common Field and Enclosure in England1450-1850,The Macmillan Press Ltd,London and Basingstoke,1977,p.147,p.215,p.216.
- [7]关于这些功能的具体内容,参见赵文洪《中世纪欧洲村庄的自治》,《世界历史》2007年第3期。
- [8]41Jerome Blum,“The Internal Structure and Polity of the EuropeanVillage Community fromthe Fifteenth to the Nineteenth Century”,The Journal of Modern History,Vol.43,No.4.(Dec.,1971),p.554,p.548.
- [9]Susan Reynolds,Kingdoms and Communities in Western Europe,900-1300,Clarendon Press,Oxford,1984,p.115,p.142,p.390.
- [10]2945Frances andJoseph Gies,Lifein a Medieval Village,Harper&Row,Publishers,NewYork,1990,p.173;p.172,p.184,p.185;pp.175-177.
- 1146G.G.Coulton,The Medieval Village,Cambridge UniversityPress,1925,pp.72-73;p.68,pp.72-73.
- 1230Warren O.Ault,“Village By-laws by Common Consent”,Speculum,Vol.29,No.2(Apr.,1954),p.390,p.389.
- 1328哈罗德.J.伯尔曼:《法律与革命——西方法律传统的形成》,贺卫方、高鸿钧、张志铭、夏勇译,中国大百科全书出版社,1993年,第397、397-399页。
- 142634Warren O.Ault,“Some Early Village By-Laws”,The EnglishHistorical Review,Vol.45,No.178(Apr.,1930),p.229,p.213,p.213.
- 15村规的起草方式也说明问题。在某村,6人小组是“经自由持有农和领主的佃农的一致同意,为村庄共同体起草村规及违规处罚条例”。参见Warren O.Ault,“Some Early Village By-Laws”,The English Historical Review,Vol.45,No.178(Apr.,1930),pp.224-225.
- 16333842J.M.Neeson,Commoners:Common Right,Enclosure andSocial Change in England,1700-1820,Cambridge UniversityPress,1993,p.24,p.141,p.143,p.176,p.111.
- 1720Robert A.Dodgshon,“The Landholding Foundations of the Open-Field System”,Past and Present,No.67(May1975).
- 18R.H.Tawney,The Agrarian Probleminthe Sixteenth Century,Lon-don,1912,p.73,p.172.
- 1921亨利.斯坦利.贝内特:《英国庄园生活1150—1400年农民生活状况研究》,龙秀清、孙立田、赵文君译,侯建新校,上海人民出版社,2005年,第34、37、42页。
- 222535Warren O.Ault,Open-Field Farmingin Medieval EnglandAStudy of Village By-Laws,George Allen&Unwin Ltd1972,NewYork,pp.26-27,p.88,p.129,p.85,p.115,p.128,p.95.
- 24Carl Dahlman,The Open Fields Systems and Beyond,Cambridge U-niversity Press,1980,p.113.
- 27Thomas Edward Scrutton,Commons and Common Fields,Or TheHistoryand Policyofthe Laws Relatingto Commons and Enclosures inEngland,Batoche Books,2003,p.66.
- 31M.A.Montague Fordham,AShort History of English Rural Life,fromthe Anglo-saxon Invasion to the Present Time,London andNewYork,1916,p.13.
- 32W.E.Tate,The English Village Communityandthe Enclosure Move-ments,London,Victor Gollancz Ltd,1967,p.31.
- 36Frederic Seebohm,The English Village Community,KennikatPress,Port Washington,NewYork and London,1883/1971,p.11.
- 37R.B.Goheen,“Peasant Politics-Village Community and the Crownin Fifteenth-Century England”,The American Historical Review,Vol.96,No.1.(Feb.,1991),p.60.
- 39Warren O.Ault,Open-Field Farming in Medieval England AStudyofVillage By-Laws,p.88,p.92.对村规样本的了解,还可参见Jane Whittle,The Development of Agrarian Capitalism,Land and Labour in Norfolk1440-1580,Clarendon Press,Ox-ford,2000,pp.317-321。
- 404748Caroline Castiglione,“Political Culture in Seventeenth-Cen-turyItalian Villages”,Journal ofInterdisciplinary History,Vol.31,No.4.(Spring,2001),pp.533-535,p.546,pp.527-528.
- 43Susan Reynolds,Kingdoms and Communities in Western Europe,900-1300,p.120.